If there is a market for industrial cyberpunk sci-fi, I hope it isn’t a very discerning audience because both The Gene Generation and Repo! The Genetic Opera have very little to offer.
The Gene Generation is a muddle. The plot is supposedly about “gene hackers,” or somesuch, but really it is about Bai Ling in industrial club gear fighting Bad Guys and occasionally taking showers.
(Oh, one last thing about the “gene hacking”—apparently it makes your body sprout all sorts of scary, yucky tentacles. Now, I’m not a scientist, but I’m pretty sure that’s not how genetics works. Unless, of course, we’re talking about Hentai Science.)
Bai Ling is at once the movie’s greatest asset and it’s greatest detriment. She has a certain appeal that will fulfill a lot of rivethead fantasies, but…she can’t act. At all. And she isn’t even the worst offender among the main cast, so I’m not sure there is really a reason to watch any of the scenes other than the ones where Ling assassinates people to a Combichrist beat. Unless, of course, you have a deep need to see Bai Ling in the shower.
(I’m not kidding about that Combichrist jab. They did approximately 90% of the soundtrack and even have a cameo. Get yr body beat ‘n’ stuff.)
But if The Gene Generation is shallow judged on its own merits, it’s Citizen Kane when watched back-to-back with Repo! The Genetic Opera. By shooting for “cult classic” status, Repo! shoots itself in the foot. Cult status can’t be quantified; it’s elusive, and the result of people genuinely recongizing something wonderful that has been overlooked by the mainstream. Repo! feels like the result of a brain-storming bull session gone horribly wrong: “Ah ha! I know what those pasty-faced, black-clad kids like! If we combine The Rocky Horror Picture Show with a ton of Hot Topic outfits, they’ll love our movie exponentially!”
No, not if they have any taste.
While there are a few interesting visual elements to Repo!, they’re swiftly swept aside by a tidal wave of plotless plot, nonsensical scenery chewing, clumsy storytelling, and interminable singing. Oh my god, the singing. There was no reason this movie should have been a musical, and there should be a law against whoever is responsible for the mind-numbing mix of opera, Avril Lavigne-weight pop punk, and atrocious industrial rock. At one point during one of the movie’s many musical numbers I realized I was frowning harder than I ever have before.
Everyone involved in this farce should feel ashamed of what they have wrought. Personally, I think Sarah Brightman is in this flick because she lost a bet.
The Gene Generation: 
Repo! The Genetic Opera: 