It's midnight, and the drummer’s fingers are impatiently tapping out what sounds suspiciously like an unintentional SOS on the snare, while scarcely masking a yawn behind her curled hand. "Come on, dad," she seems to be pleading with her father, who's holding forth in a protracted monologue stage left, "Can't you see how badly we're not rocking?"
The fingers belong to Rachel Trachtenburg, the 14-year-old drummer/ukulele-player/singer/daughter of The Trachtenburg Family Slideshow Players, whose Morse code translated the apparent sentiments of many of the fifty guests at the Knitting Factory performance in NYC on September 27.
I hadn't seen TFSP previously, and having heard only praise, watching the show felt as though I was desperately stuffing myself with a highly-recommended fine imported cheese, perhaps a Stinking Bishop. The Bishop was so sour, however, I couldn't tell if the taste was intentional. I kept eating it anyway, since I didn't want to waste it, and it was too late to run to the store for more. Maybe, I thought, I'm missing something.
The excruciating tension and sweaty anxiety onstage was an unnerving burden to experience, and I wondered if there had been a family argument before the show, or if the band chemistry was always so painful to watch. Many nervous excuses were made during the course of the evening for the musical and technical shortcomings. These were usually in the form of ironically esoteric one-liners which fell flat on the floor in front of a nonplussed, hello-is-this-thing-on crowd.
TFSP is a trio, which includes guitarist/keyboardist/singer/father Jason, slideshow performer/backing vocalist/mother Tina Piña, and Rachel. The band has scratched a name for themselves into the bathroom stall of music history by bringing to life one of those late-night brainstorms most of us simply shrug off the following morning. Their formula involves sculpting gently rocking indie folk tunes based on stories invented from slide collections they find at estate sales, and performing the songs to a slideshow backdrop.
They have developed a business founded upon a clever set of gimmicks, and proudly so. It appeared the intended effect was for the audience to join the Players in their gleeful fight against mainstream corporate media. What translated instead was an unabashed attempt to submerge the audience into a cold and predatory guilt-bath of forced sympathy.
…Or maybe it was just an off night.
Trachtenboring.

The opening bands were:
Anamanaguchi
Earnest, brilliant and note-perfect, anamanaguchi was the most fun I've had at a show in years. The songs are instantly and persistently catchy and predominantly thematic. Offspring and Weezer have merged and perform a thrilling soundtrack to Dig-Dug. The meticulously constructed and executed pieces made me want to throw my hands up and cheer (given the tiny venue, I refrained), as though it was my collegiate brother whose band might just make it big. 8-bits sound like 64, and chiptune has never sounded so organic.
Beep! Strum!

Pleaseeasaur
Much like watching Saturday Night Live, I truly wanted to laugh, but found few opportunities to do so. I was uncomfortable with the tangible and pervasive angry undertone of the performer, JP Hasson, as though he might snap at any moment and murder us all. The retro-spiced motivational late-night TV meets high school auditorium multimedia presentation might perhaps have read better if interspersed with varying flavors.
Pleasenomore.

Luckily, after the downstairs show, the doorman Richie suggested I check out the upstairs revue, and I’m so pleased I did.
Hosted by Kaiju Big Battel
Yessssssss!

Tsu Shi Ma Mi Re
More energy than Gojira: near-perfect rock!

BakuBeni
Not so much.

Playing earlier during the downstairs shows (i.e., unseen):
Echostream
Falsies On Heat
Quaff
The Notorious MSG
MiniRex
NOTE: Knitting Factory will be relocating after December 31, 2008 to the Luna Lounge in Williamsburg.
Review by Jason Dragon.
Jason Dragon coined the terms "smugster" and "The Shatner Effect," and has been writing reviews since the day he was born ("The performance space was too dark and claustrophobic, and the sound was muffled – John Cage did it better years ago.").